A
recent article that was referenced in a “tweet” from a fellow tax pro stated “Actually Burger King has been trying to
dodge taxes for years!!”.
As
if this was a surprising discovery. And
as if it was something wrong – illegal, immoral, or unethical – with this
practice.
I
do not know a single person or company that does not try to “dodge” taxes. I do it, both for myself and my clients, and
so do you.
There
is absolutely nothing illegal, immoral, or unethical with trying to “dodge”
taxes. By “dodge” I mean “avoid”.
“Over and over again, courts have said that
there is nothing sinister in arranging one’s affairs as to keep taxes as low as
possible. Everybody does so, rich and poor; and all do right, for nobody owes
any public duty to pay more than the law demands: taxes are enforced exactions,
not voluntary contributions.” Judge
Billings Learned Hand
“
. . . [t]he legal right of a taxpayer to
decrease the amount of what otherwise would be his taxes, or altogether avoid
them, by means which the law permits, cannot be doubted.” Justice George Sutherland
In
my 40+ years of preparing 1040s for taxpayers in all walks of life a client has
never told me “No thanks, I would rather pay more taxes” in response to my
advising them of a legitimate tax deduction or credit to which they are entitled.
The
latest fascination with “tax inversions”, and US companies moving overseas to
reduce their tax bill, seems to suggest that taking advantage of this totally
kosher strategy is, if not illegal, immoral and unethical.
When
it comes to public companies, they actually have a fiduciary responsibility to
their shareholders to properly "manage" expenses such as income taxes.
If
it is perfectly alright for me to do whatever I can to legally reduce my tax
bill, why is it not also alright for Burger King?
If the law allows a taxpayer to deduct his mortgage interest don’t chastise the taxpayer for doing so. The taxpayer would be stupid not to do so.
If
a tax deduction, credit, or strategy seems to be immoral, unethical, or unfair
it is the fault of the idiots in Congress for writing the Tax Code to allow
such a deduction, credit, or strategy.
The
only obligation an individual or corporate taxpayer owes to the government is
to file an honest tax return – to report all taxable income, to deduct only
legitimate deductions, and to claim only legitimate credits.
There
is no doubt that much of our current Tax Code is “unfair”. Our current Tax Code is truly a mucking fess. And the fault lies directly on the shoulders
of the idiots in Congress, who line their pockets with “gifts” from lobbyists, and
seek votes from groups of taxpayers, in exchange for legislating specialized tax loopholes.
The
US Tax Code needs to be rewritten from scratch to be simple and fair. But don’t hold your breath.
TTFN
